• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • HOME
  • NEWS+OPINIONS
    • NEWS TO US
    • COLUMNS
      • APPARENT HORIZON
      • DEAR READER
      • Close
    • LONGFORM FEATURES
    • OPINIONS
    • EDITORIAL
    • Close
  • ARTS+ENTERTAINMENT
    • FILM
    • MUSIC
    • COMEDY
    • PERFORMING ARTS
    • VISUAL ARTS
    • Close
  • DINING+DRINKING
    • EATS
    • SIPS
    • Close
  • LIFESTYLE
    • CANNABIS
      • TALKING JOINTS MEMO
      • Close
    • WELLNESS
    • GTFO
    • Close
  • STUFF TO DO
  • TICKETS
  • ABOUT US
    • ABOUT
    • MASTHEAD
    • ADVERTISE
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • Close
  • BECOME A MEMBER

Dig Bos

The Dig - Boston's Only Newspaper

CURRENT STREET EDITION

DIG 23.05 – 4/8/21

NOTES ON: MLB ON FOX

Written by CADEN MARK GARDNER Posted September 10, 2020 Filed Under: A+E, Film

Image via Fox Sports on Youtube

“That a company like Fox will likely work to smooth out this technology rather than scrap it—football season is around the corner, after all—means the virtual fans will likely be getting ‘better’ over time.”


Something like this happened before. Recall how amid protests against the killing of Freddie Gray in Baltimore during the 2015 baseball season, a Chicago White Sox/Baltimore Orioles game held in Camden Yards on April 29 resembled something closer to the end of Michelangelo Antonioni’s L’eclisse (1962)—it was crowdless. The teams were the only people visible, along with sports photographers popping up around the lower level, in what was widely considered the first “fanless game” ever played in Major League Baseball history. The Orioles decided to play without fans to avoid draining police resources in the midst of the protests, and because there was no other time to reschedule the game. The resulting images were surreal. Orioles announcer Gary Thorne spoke in whispering tones as if to mimic professional golf announcers. After catching the third out to end one inning, then-Orioles star Chris Davis tossed a baseball into the stands to an imagined fan. 

While you could argue that a multibillion dollar business continuing a game in what was a ground zero of social and political unrest ignored the bigger picture, the fanless game also showed that even professional baseball was not immune from the reality on the ground. And of course in our current moment the fanless game has become the new normal, illustrating that very same fact yet again. However, Major League Baseball and one of its broadcasting partners are, if not in denial, then unable to accept this new normal without being a little bit weird about it: “Virtual fans” have become a fixture on Fox Saturday Baseball since late July, and the reviews have been mixed at best.

Image via post by user engineeringhistory on Youtube (and Fox Sports)

Fox Sports has gone off the beaten path before with its broadcasting “innovations.” Remember when it had “FoxTrax” for its hockey telecast to make the puck glow on screen, because Fox thought Americans would only watch hockey if they were able to more consistently track the puck? But this latest broadcasting quirk puts the channel less in sports broadcasting innovations like instant replay and more into the realm of an internet “deep fake.” 

The network has stated the intended purpose for these virtual fans was to distract from the reality that stadiums were empty due to the pandemic. Initial fan reactions were befuddled, noting the inconsistencies of certain camera angles having the virtual fans while other angles did not, resulting in fakes that would appear and disappear even within a single play. These virtual fans are, thankfully, inaudible—with the broadcasts and the stadiums themselves cranking in sounds instead (most notably the Oakland Athletics, who’ve had their most famous supporter, Tom Hanks, record his voice in the role of a hot dog vendor to be played in the Coliseum). Those audio effects are more in the tradition of older media, like a canned laugh track for a multi-camera sitcom, or a pop song that mixes in live-crowd noise to create the illusion of a live song. But there is something more appropriately dystopian about this presentation on the visual side—in the virtual fans, and Fox’s insistence on presenting “them” in every telecast. 

Image from Max Headroom, courtesy Shout Factory

Such an event of artificial intelligence in normally human spaces was predicted on television over 30 years ago by Max Headroom, once described as “the world’s first computer-generated [TV] host.” The character’s backstory is established in Max Headroom: 20 Minutes Into the Future (1985), a dark, cyberpunk, made-for-television media satire staged in an Art Deco landscape. Investigative reporter Edison Carter (Matt Frewer), while sedated, has his mind recorded by his employer, the evil media corporation Network 23, to create a digitized version of himself—Max Headroom. The success of the TV movie led to an American television series that went for two seasons (1987-88), with Max Headroom also spinning off into an ad man for products like New Coke and appearing on David Letterman. Like the virtual fans we see in baseball, Max Headroom was less uncanny valley but instead so much jankier: with a head similar to a Ken Doll, a molded mane rather than hair, and a stuttering electronic voice that made him sound like a computer-age Porky Pig. 

In some ways it’s comforting to see that these beings of technology are hardly perfect. But at the same time, that a company like Fox will likely work to smooth out this technology rather than scrap it—football season is around the corner, after all—means the virtual fans will likely be getting “better” over time. And while it might seem like this effect will only be used to shield the image of empty stadiums until sports leagues are permitted to seat attendees once more, there are worthwhile questions to be asked about virtual fans reemerging as real-people substitutes again. Do these virtual fans fill out future marches? Political speeches? Even concerts? There are so many potential possibilities, some of which should at least give us pause—but perhaps we are too far past the rubicon to effectively protest them? A lot of technology starts as a joke and regardless of the warning cries of a few Cassandras, those jokes beget dark policies and operations that get hastily normalized in the name of power and capital. Fox might not be Network 23-level evil just for introducing the virtual fan, but there are well-founded reasons to find its existence crass, tone-deaf, and unsettling on aesthetic and ethical levels.

CADEN MARK GARDNER

Caden Mark Gardner is a freelance film critic from Upstate New York

More from author
  • CADEN MARK GARDNER
    https://digboston.com/author/caden-mark-gardner/
    PERFORMANCE REVIEW: "MY FIRST FILM" AT THE BRATTLE
  • CADEN MARK GARDNER
    https://digboston.com/author/caden-mark-gardner/
    FILM REVIEW: "I WAS AT HOME, BUT..."
  • CADEN MARK GARDNER
    https://digboston.com/author/caden-mark-gardner/
    FILM REVIEW: "COLD WEATHER" AND "GEMINI" AT THE HFA

Filed Under: A+E, Film Tagged With: arts, Film, slider

WHAT’S NEW

PICS & RECAP: JUSTICE 4 DUANTE WRIGHT JUSTICE 4 ALL EMERGENCY RALLY 

PICS & RECAP: JUSTICE 4 DUANTE WRIGHT JUSTICE 4 ALL EMERGENCY RALLY 

A SHORT DOC ABOUT HOW DIGBOSTON WEATHERED A PANDEMIC YEAR

A SHORT DOC ABOUT HOW DIGBOSTON WEATHERED A PANDEMIC YEAR

FULL PARKING ENFORCEMENT RETURNS TO BOSTON, BLUEBIKES STILL AVAIL FOR ESSENTIAL WORKERS

FULL PARKING ENFORCEMENT RETURNS TO BOSTON, BLUEBIKES STILL AVAIL FOR ESSENTIAL WORKERS

EMERGENCY PRESS CONFERENCE AND RALLY FOR DAUNTE WRIGHT

EMERGENCY PRESS CONFERENCE AND RALLY FOR DAUNTE WRIGHT

POLITICIANS GET IN LINE TO CALL FOR BOSTON POLICE ACCOUNTABILITY

POLITICIANS GET IN LINE TO CALL FOR BOSTON POLICE ACCOUNTABILITY

PARENTS RELEASE AN ANALYSIS OF BOSTON PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDRAISING INEQUITIES

PARENTS RELEASE AN ANALYSIS OF BOSTON PUBLIC SCHOOL FUNDRAISING INEQUITIES

Primary Sidebar

HEMPIRE FREEDOM PACK 25% OFF

FEATURED EVENT

Most Popular

  • VACCINE EQUITY NOW! COALITION ASKS BAKER TO ALLOCATE 20% OF NEW DOSES TO HARD HIT COMMUNITIES by SHIRA LAUCHAROEN
  • IF YOU’RE SURPRISED THE BPD CODDLED AN ACCUSED MOLESTER COP, YOU’RE NOT PAYING ATTENTION by CHRIS FARAONE
  • rally to protest discrimination and crimes against Asian and Pacific islanders during Stop Asian Hate rally on Boston Common in Boston PICS & RECAP: “STOP ASIAN HATE BOSTON” RALLY ON THE COMMON by KEIKO HIROMI
  • A FAREWELL TRIBUTE (OF SORTS) TO MARTY WALSH by DIG STAFF
  • THE MYSTERY OF CHEZ TORTONI by CHRISTOPHER EHLERS

READ CURRENT MEMBER EDITION

DIG Member 2.1 – March 2021

READ CURRENT STREET ISSUE

DIG 23.05 – 4/8/21

Footer

digbos

digbos
“My administration is doubling down on our work “My administration is doubling down on our work to stand up the #Boston Office of #Police Accountability and Transparency.” https://digboston.com/politicians-get-in-line-to-call-for-boston-police-accountability/ #politics #Massachusetts
This week is your last chance to hit up Mooby’s This week is your last chance to hit up Mooby’s in #Boston … https://digboston.com/moobys-boston-how-kevin-smith-has-brought-his-pick-up-experience-to-10-cities-during-the-pandemic/ #fan #popup #fun #restaurant #movie #Massachusetts #snoochieboochies
The group is asking that polices address the dispa The group is asking that polices address the disparities the #data has revealed. https://digboston.com/parents-release-an-analysis-of-boston-public-school-fundraising-inequities/ #education #school #public #study #fundraising #racism #Boston #Massachusetts
“We’re not going to survive for 20 more years “We’re not going to survive for 20 more years if we don’t do this [move to a bigger space].” https://digboston.com/how-juliet-hit-a-100k-kickstarter-goal-in-4-days/ #restaurant #business #food #crowdfund #SomervilleMA #coronavirus #COVID19
EDITORIAL: DIGBOSTON SEEKS CLIMATE IDEAS FOR MAYOR EDITORIAL: DIGBOSTON SEEKS CLIMATE IDEAS FOR MAYOR KIM JANEY. Environmental organizations and individual activists invited to submit opinion articles for publication. https://digboston.com/editorial-digboston-seeks-climate-ideas-for-mayor-kim-janey/ #politics @boston_mayor #environment #globalwarming #climate #activist #callforsubmissions #policy #Boston #Massachusetts
“Most are some of my favorite bars or local clas “Most are some of my favorite bars or local classics that I’ve learned to love in my time living in the city. Others just have a great facade that I know would make a great drawing.” https://digboston.com/drawn-but-not-forgotten-local-artist-sketches-beloved-boston-restaurants/ #art #artist #sketch #drawing #Boston #Massachusetts #bar #restaurant
Despite #pandemic hurdles, Mass #music instructors Despite #pandemic hurdles, Mass #music instructors hit new high notes. “My #teaching has gone to another level.” https://digboston.com/the-medium-is-the-maestro/ #education #Massachusetts #coronavirus #COVID19
From the podcast to the book, Wayne Federman chron From the podcast to the book, Wayne Federman chronicles the business of joke-telling. https://digboston.com/the-history-of-stand-up-from-mark-twain-to-dave-chappelle/ #comedy #history #book #interview #Boston #Massachusetts
“I’m calling on some of you to drop by a local “I’m calling on some of you to drop by a local field office and hear what people have to say.” https://digboston.com/dear-reader-the-political-season-is-upon-us-embrace-it/ #politics #commentary #election #Massachusetts
“I think most people agree that we want our publ “I think most people agree that we want our public dollars to go to those companies that are not cutting corners.” https://digboston.com/bill-seeks-to-penalize-contractors-for-unsafe-conditions/ #politics #legislation #construction #safety #labor #Massachusetts
Load More... Follow on Instagram
Social Buttons

DigBoston facebook DigBoston Twitter DigBoston Instagram

Masthead

About

Submissions

Advertise

Privacy Policy

Customer Service

Distribution

About Us

DigBoston is a one-stop nexus for everything worth doing or knowing in the Boston area. It's an alt-weekly, it's a website, it's an e-mail blast, it's a twitter account, it's that cool party that you were at last night ... hey, you're reading it, so it's gotta be good. For advertising inquiries: [email protected] To reach Editorial: [email protected] For internship opportunities: [email protected]