• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • HOME
  • NEWS+OPINIONS
    • NEWS TO US
    • COLUMNS
      • APPARENT HORIZON
      • DEAR READER
      • Close
    • LONGFORM FEATURES
    • OPINIONS
    • EDITORIAL
    • Close
  • ARTS+ENTERTAINMENT
    • FILM
    • MUSIC
    • COMEDY
    • PERFORMING ARTS
    • VISUAL ARTS
    • Close
  • DINING+DRINKING
    • EATS
    • SIPS
    • Close
  • LIFESTYLE
    • CANNABIS
      • TALKING JOINTS MEMO
      • Close
    • WELLNESS
    • GTFO
    • Close
  • STUFF TO DO
  • TICKETS
  • ABOUT US
    • 5 DOUBLE-U’S
    • MASTHEAD
    • DISTRIBUTION
    • ADVERTISE
    • SUBMISSIONS
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • Close
  • BECOME A MEMBER

Dig Bos

The Dig - Boston's Only Newspaper

CURRENT STREET EDITION

DIG 23.02 – 1/28/21

SPECIAL GUEST COLUMN: CONTROLLING THE CONNECTION

Written by SAUL TANNENBAUM Posted May 22, 2017 Filed Under: COLUMNS, News, NEWS+OPINIONS

Municipal broadband is municipal resistance

 

On the first day of his administration, President Donald Trump appointed Ajit Pai as chair of the Federal Communications Commission. Already a commissioner, Pai didn’t need Senate confirmation.

 

On the second day of the Trump administration, bolstered by the long time ambitions of conservative think tanks, Pai began to undo all the good work the FCC did in the last few years of the Obama administration. Internet privacy protections proposals? Gone. Net neutrality? Internet service providers, in the Republican world, have a First Amendment right to express themselves by speeding the traffic of web sites they favor and slowing that of web sites they don’t. Federal programs to subsidize broadband for the poor? Being dismantled, step by step, and, in some cases, turned into cash grants to the very companies that have been under-serving the poor.

 

The FCC itself? It needs to be “modernized” and its regulatory powers stripped and moved to the Federal Trade Commission, a body with neither the rule-making powers nor the expertise of the FCC. Corporate consolidation? Time to leverage those synergies. Price caps for monopoly broadband providers to businesses, schools, and libraries? Lifted.

 

Harvard Law School’s Susan Crawford, one of the nation’s preeminent scholars of telecommunication policy, calls this a “catastrophe.”

 

The telecommunications companies have wasted no time. Verizon announced a “gigabit” internet service which, the company admits, can’t reach gigabit speeds. All three wireless companies have introduced “unlimited” plans that, instead, have clear limits. Wireless and wireline companies have introduced cross-promotions that make it difficult to understand from whom you’re buying services. Sprint and T-Mobile are discussing a merger that had been shot down during the Obama presidency. None of these initiatives are about giving customers reliable, affordable high speed networking. They are, instead, about each company building a bubble of digital entertainment to surround you everywhere, ready for you when you cut the cord of traditional television.

 

The last bastion of a free, fair, and open internet is network neutrality, the principle that internet service providers must treat all network services equally. Pai seeks to squash this, the facts be damned. In a recent speech explaining his plan to dismantle net neutrality, something he considers government intrusion, he said, the “internet is the greatest free-market success story in history.” This is bullshit. The government funded and created the internet. The people who did the work weren’t entrepreneurs, but were instead academics and engineers who gave away their intellectual property without even thinking about compensation. The government privatized the internet in the mid-1990s, allowing corporations to profit from taxpayer-funded research. Ironically, at the time, large telecommunications companies fought the internet, trying desperately to keep it off their dialup phone systems.

 

And if all this wasn’t bad enough, the FCC itself sought to portray those defending net neutrality as unhinged in the form of Pai’s chief of staff tweeting, “Very sad to see racist, hate-filled attacks against Chairman Pai being submitted to the FCC.”

 

The article to which that tweet links notes that, out of 1.5 million comments, thousands of comments using fake names and bots posing as “Jesus Christ,” “Michael Jackson,” “Homer Simpson,” and “Melania Trump” … Over 500 were submitted using Chairman Pai’s name, as well as 189 from “Donald Trump” and eight from “Obama.” Eleven submissions used some version of the word “f — k.”

 

Eleven fucks out of 1.5 million comments seems rather restrained.

 

Government activism in promoting communication technologies is, literally, as old as America. It’s the US Constitution that grants the federal government the power to create the postal service and build postal roads. The 1792 Postal Act utilized that power to actually create a state of the art communications network, the printed word distributed by riders on horses. The postal system itself, according to scholars, was structured not to promote private profit, but to create a public sphere of newspapers.

 

When the previous Chair of the FCC, Tom Wheeler — an unabashed capitalist — looked at the broadband marketplace, he concluded that the free market had failed. His response was to call for activism via local governments: “When commercial providers don’t step up to serve a community’s needs, we should embrace the great American tradition of citizens stepping up to take action collectively.”

 

If an unrepentant capitalist sounds like a socialist — and means it — attention should be paid.

 

Wheeler believed that, even under the most stringent regulatory power his agency could muster, there was a strong case for the collective action of citizens acting through their local governments to build their own broadband networks. With the actions of the last few months, if you care about a free and open internet, there’s really no alternative.

 

There’s nothing magic about a fiber optic computer network. These networks have been routinely installed for decades and are well understood. Indeed, if a city were to build one, they’d likely employ the same consultants and contractors as the private sector. The advantages of municipal control lie in policy. While policy fights are taking place at the national level, they are really decided by whose cable connects your home and what policies they adopt. These have become national issues because, while we used to have large numbers of small ISPs, we now have a very small number of very large ISPs.

 

If you want an ISP that doesn’t track your every online move, you can ensure that through municipal broadband. If you want an ISP that treats all web sites, big and small, mainstream or radical, the same, you can ensure that through municipal broadband. Care about the cost of access for the economically less fortunate? Your municipal provider can set up a rate structure to provide broadband regardless of the ability to pay. Worried about corporate consolidation of communications? A municipal broadband system adds another player to the market. And, if you don’t want a telecommunications company building you a walled garden of its own information and entertainment services, a municipal broadband system would avoid that.

 

There’s been a stirring of interest in municipal broadband in the Boston area. Concord has built a fiber-to-the-home broadband network, as have Braintree, Reading, and Norwood.

 

Boston has chosen a different approach—one of partnering with Verizon, which seeks to use Boston to demonstrate to Wall Street that it is a company looking to the future of digital entertainment and smart cities. Boston officials are acutely aware of the risks of this strategy, but believe that a $800 million municipal network is, politically, a nonstarter.

 

Cambridge chose to investigate broadband choices a few years ago and appointed a citizen Task Force. The report of the Task Force, of which this author was a member, showed that a municipal network would cost about $180 million. That, for wealthy Cambridge, is the cost of a school, which is to say, a level of social investment it routinely makes. The Task Force report has been sitting with no visible action or comment since last fall.

 

While we should all be following John Oliver’s advice and flooding the FCC with comments about net neutrality, we should also understand that national telecommunications policy in the US is as bald an expression of oligarchy as we can see. Consider, for a moment, Mike Huckabee, a man who hates his ISP at least as much as you do. If mainstream Republicans like Huckabee feel this way, why is their party pursuing policies that provide no incentive for ISPs to improve services and let them vacuum up more of our money? With federal policy firmly in the hands of the telecommunications industry, we need to look for other solutions. It’s time to demand that local governments treat modern broadband networks like they do streets and sidewalks, a part of the connective fiber of a vibrant community. If the newly emergent American nation can build roads, we can build fiber optic networks to enhance the public sphere. The alternative is a communications future controlled by a handful of companies for the benefit of their stockholders, not the public.

 

Oh, and Mike Huckabee? He got something the rest of us never do, a public apology from Comcast.

SAUL TANNENBAUM
More from author
  • SAUL TANNENBAUM
    https://digboston.com/author/saul-tannenbaum/
    UT Chancellor William McRaven at LBJ Library CIA President's Daily Brief Release Event. LBJ Library photo by Gabriel Cristóver Pérez. Public Domain.
    MIT’S COMMENCEMENT SPEAKER HAS HIS OWN CIVILIAN DEATH TOLL
  • SAUL TANNENBAUM
    https://digboston.com/author/saul-tannenbaum/
    THE EPSTEIN STENCH
  • SAUL TANNENBAUM
    https://digboston.com/author/saul-tannenbaum/
    section of Harvard Square Neighborhood Association flyer modified by Saul Tannenbaum
    COUNTERPOINT: PROGRESSIVES AGAINST PROGRESS
  • SAUL TANNENBAUM
    https://digboston.com/author/saul-tannenbaum/
    THE YEAR WE LOST NET NEUTRALITY

Filed Under: COLUMNS, News, NEWS+OPINIONS Tagged With: 1792 Postal Act, Ajit Pai, Boston, Braintree, Cambridge, FCC, Federal Trade Commission, Massachusetts, net neutrality, Norwood, President Donald Trump, Reading, Saul Tannenbaum, Susan Crawford, telecommunications

WHAT’S NEW

Gov. Charlie Baker announces an educator vaccine program Wednesday in a WCVB screen capture.

STATE ADDS 400,000 EDUCATORS TO LIST FOR VACCINE

INBOX: JOHN BARROS LAUNCHES CAMPAIGN FOR MAYOR OF BOSTON

INBOX: JOHN BARROS LAUNCHES CAMPAIGN FOR MAYOR OF BOSTON

TRUMP GUY WINS THE DEMOCRATIC PRIMARY TO FILL DELEO’S SEAT

TRUMP GUY WINS THE DEMOCRATIC PRIMARY TO FILL DELEO’S SEAT

CHECKING IN ON THE COMMONWEALTH’S COMPREHENSIVE CLIMATE BILL

CHECKING IN ON THE COMMONWEALTH’S COMPREHENSIVE CLIMATE BILL

YOUNG VOTERS, OLD GAME

YOUNG VOTERS, OLD GAME

CAMPBELL ORDERS INFORMATION ON OFFICER’S INVOLVEMENT IN CAPITOL ATTACK

CAMPBELL ORDERS INFORMATION ON OFFICER’S INVOLVEMENT IN CAPITOL ATTACK

Primary Sidebar

HEMPIRE FREEDOM PACK 25% OFF

FEATURED EVENT

Most Popular

  • SPECIAL FEATURE ON THE MASS STATE POLICE: TROOPER WILSON’S WAR by CHRIS FARAONE
  • [UPDATE: WE GOT IT!] WHERE IS THE CONTRACT FOR MASSACHUSETTS’ VACCINE APPOINTMENT SOFTWARE? by POLINA WHITEHOUSE
  • BOSTON LATIN ACADEMY GRADS FIGHT FOR REPRESENTATION IN ALUMNI GROUP by CHRIS FARAONE
  • MASS KEEPS TRYING TO BUILD A NEW WOMEN’S PRISON OUTSIDE OF PUBLIC VIEW by DAN ATKINSON
  • WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON WITH MASSACHUSETTS POLITICS AND VACCINATIONS? by ZACK HUFFMAN

READ CURRENT MEMBER EDITION

DIG Member 1.9 – 11/26/20

READ CURRENT STREET ISSUE

DIG 23.02 – 1/28/21

Footer

digbos

digbos
“No one wants to live in a world where music is “No one wants to live in a world where music is created to please a cold-blooded algorithm.” https://buff.ly/2OmuqPR #surveillance #interview #politics #tecnology
Barros is the fifth mayoral candidate to enter the Barros is the fifth mayoral candidate to enter the race. https://buff.ly/3bj3EAW #politics #election #Boston #Massachusetts
Can a veteran of the Wisconsin Uprising and former Can a veteran of the Wisconsin Uprising and former Mass union leader rescue the IAFF? https://digboston.com/a-firefighter-election/ #labor #firefighter #union #election #opinion #WisconsinUprising #Massachusetts #national
New #report shows 1/6 of women in Mass prisons sen New #report shows 1/6 of women in Mass prisons sentenced to life without parole. https://digboston.com/commonwealth-committed-to-other-death-penalty/ #prison #prisoner #humanrights #criticism #Massachusetts
“The gratuitous militarization of police forces “The gratuitous militarization of police forces across the United States facilitated by this program has helped to turn these agencies into brutal weapons of repression.” https://digboston.com/inbox-group-calls-for-biden-to-abolish-police-militarization-program/ #police #reform #criticism #Massachusetts
It’s the second time in less than a year that pr It’s the second time in less than a year that progressives have been dealt a bitter defeat in a crowded primary race. https://digboston.com/trump-guy-wins-the-democratic-primary-to-fill-deleos-seat/ #politics #election #Democrats #primary #legislature #Winthrop #Revere  #Massachusetts #MAGA #herp #derp
As lawmakers consider Baker’s amendments to clim As lawmakers consider Baker’s amendments to climate bill, the fight for environmental justice continues. https://digboston.com/checking-in-on-the-commonwealths-comprehensive-climate-bill/ #politics #legislature #environment #activism #globalwarming #Massachusetts
AS LABOR SECRETARY, WILL MARTY WALSH REPRESENT ALL AS LABOR SECRETARY, WILL MARTY WALSH REPRESENT ALL WORKERS? Or just unionized construction workers… and the corporations that fund the Democrats. The latest from DigBoston's @jasonpramas. https://digboston.com/as-labor-secretary-will-marty-walsh-represent-all-workers/ #politics #labor #union #work #national #analysis #Boston #Massachusetts
Includes Gang Green, The Freeze, SIEGE, TREE, and Includes Gang Green, The Freeze, SIEGE, TREE, and many more. https://digboston.com/iconic-lineup-comes-through-to-support-nantasket-venue-through-pandemic/ #music #digital #benefit #Hull #Massachusetts
Our interview with Avi Loeb, author of “Extrater Our interview with Avi Loeb, author of “Extraterrestrial: The First Sign of Intelligent Life Beyond Earth.” https://buff.ly/2O3nlUd #interview #book #alien #technology #astronomy #controversy #debate #science #Boston #Massachusetts
Load More... Follow on Instagram
Social Buttons

DigBoston facebook DigBoston Twitter DigBoston Instagram

Masthead

About

Submissions

Advertise

Privacy Policy

Customer Service

Distribution

About Us

DigBoston is a one-stop nexus for everything worth doing or knowing in the Boston area. It's an alt-weekly, it's a website, it's an e-mail blast, it's a twitter account, it's that cool party that you were at last night ... hey, you're reading it, so it's gotta be good. For advertising inquiries: [email protected] To reach Editorial: [email protected] For internship opportunities: [email protected]