• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • HOME
  • NEWS+OPINIONS
    • NEWS TO US
    • COLUMNS
      • APPARENT HORIZON
      • DEAR READER
      • Close
    • LONGFORM FEATURES
    • OPINIONS
    • EDITORIAL
    • Close
  • ARTS+ENTERTAINMENT
    • FILM
    • MUSIC
    • COMEDY
    • PERFORMING ARTS
    • VISUAL ARTS
    • Close
  • DINING+DRINKING
    • EATS
    • SIPS
    • Close
  • LIFESTYLE
    • CANNABIS
      • TALKING JOINTS MEMO
      • Close
    • WELLNESS
    • GTFO
    • Close
  • STUFF TO DO
  • TICKETS
  • ABOUT US
    • 5 DOUBLE-U’S
    • MASTHEAD
    • DISTRIBUTION
    • ADVERTISE
    • SUBMISSIONS
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • Close
  • BECOME A MEMBER

Dig Bos

The Dig - Boston's Only Newspaper

READ CURRENT STREET ISSUE

DIG Year End 2020

THERE IS NOTHING ‘VOLUNTARY’ ABOUT WORKING BAD JOBS

Written by JASON PRAMAS Posted January 28, 2020 Filed Under: Apparent Horizon, COLUMNS, NEWS+OPINIONS

 

A brief defense of AOC’s critique of billionaires

 

Every once in a while I like to poke my head over the disintegrating ramparts of the Boston Herald to see what reactionary night soil they’re spewing at their rapidly shrinking audience of aging South Shore incels. 

 

With so few paid reporters left, its editors are leaning rather more heavily on whatever syndicated content they can inexpensively reprint. So I was unsurprised to see that they ran a column by right-winger Ben Shapiro on Monday inveighing against one of their biggest bete noires, AOC. Insultingly titled “Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez needs crash course in economics.”

 

It seems the internet celebrity was unhappy with a statement that the congresswoman from NYC made at an MLK Day event with Ta-Nehisi Coates: “No one ever makes a billion dollars. You take a billion dollars.”

 

Truer words were never spoken by an American politician. But they are not words that are typically allowed to go unchallenged by media specialists working in the service of the rich and powerful. So a loyal conservative flack like Shapiro felt it was necessary to leap to the defense of the global elite. The goal apparently being to squelch any funny ideas that working-class readers might get about questioning their “betters” like AOC did. Herself a working-class Latina with a college education who was, until her recent elevation to the national political stage by people just like her, a bartender.

 

During the MLK exchange, Coates, in the role of “Joe Billionaire,” said “…[T]hose billions of dollars are mine. Why am I the enemy of healthcare?”

 

To which Ocasio-Cortez replied, “You sat on a couch while thousands of people were paid modern-day slave wages,” and stated that billionaires make their money “off the backs” of undocumented immigrants, people of color, and single mothers who are all “literally dying because they can’t afford to live,” according to Business Insider.

 

Shapiro, in his dispatch, responded precisely as anyone with any experience dealing with capitalist apologists would expect him to. “This, of course, is nonsense,” he wrote. “Voluntary exchange of labor for wages is, as stated, voluntary, and the fact that there are many people willing and able to labor in the manufacture of widgets is presumably responsible for lower wages. Companies that refuse to pay their workers market wages will soon watch those workers migrate to other businesses or other industries. It is a patent violation of free market principles to utilize force in order to compel someone to work for you; blaming the free market for coercion is like blaming free speech for censorship. Exploitation in labor markets is typically accompanied by government subsidies, regulation and interventionism.”

 

As usual with commentators of his ilk, one has to ask oneself if he actually believes this tripe because he is the pampered offspring of well-off LA parents and simply doesn’t know what it’s like to be a member of America’s beleaguered working class, or if he is unwilling to admit that he’s cherry-picking his arguments because they suit his line of attack.

 

Either way, he does a serviceable job of channeling the same nostrums that corporate leaders and their publicists have been spouting since Milton Friedman and other neoliberal thinkers concocted them decades back as an excuse to crush the labor movement and increase profits for their corporate masters. With a hearty assist from the mass media said masters own at all levels, as I mentioned in my column of last week, “Sins of Omission: Mainstream News Media Must End Its Anti-Socialist Bias.”

 

So I must retort with a simple fact that every person who has tried to survive in the savage battle royal that is the labor “market” of 21st-century America already knows from painful personal experience: There is absolutely nothing “voluntary” about working the bad jobs that the economy controlled by the billionaires in question create for them.

 

Shapiro’s basic conceit, like that of many right-wing libertarians before him, is basically that if working people don’t like the deal they’re getting at a particular job, they can go get another one.

 

Yet, increasingly, most of the jobs available to workers in most parts of the US are equally terrible—temp, day labor, contract, part time, and independent contractor gigs with no long-term (or even medium-term) security and few, if any benefits.

 

The options for too many workers—especially those who can’t afford college thanks to diminishing public support for higher education—are choices between these bad contingent jobs with heartless conglomerates like Amazon, Walmart, and Uber. That is, no options at all. They all suck. They are all unstable. Their outrageously powerful owners all use tricks backed by pro-boss legislation passed by bought-and-paid-for politicians to sustain the legal fiction that their workforces are a bunch of independent businesspeople who are not their employees—and are therefore owed nothing more than companies are willing to pay them. Mere pittances that they do everything in their power to keep artificially depressed. All in the interest of fattening the bottom line for themselves and their shareholders. 

 

Such billionaire proprietors work people until their health fails or they get injured or killed on the job (at which point they do their level best to duck responsibility for those mishaps and force any resultant catastrophic financial consequences onto the backs of the families of the victims).

 

So, far from any imaginary “free market,” today’s economy is structured from top to bottom to serve the interests of a tiny percentage of rich people and exploit the multitudes of working people—including the downwardly mobile group of mostly white educated workers formerly known as the middle class.

 

This situation, this war between labor and capital, has been going on for as long as capitalism has existed, and it can only change for the better for working people if our federal government is forced to heavily regulate the corporations that wish to do business here by moving the US toward a European-style social democracy of the type that Bernie Sanders and AOC call for (and Shapiro explicitly rejects), or if we move toward a democratic socialist system where working people own the means of production. Built on the solid foundation of—among other popular institutions—worker co-operatives of the very type that Ocasio-Cortez spoke positively of in her conversation with Coates, and Shapiro unsuccessfully attempted to dismiss in his column… by mischaracterizing the travails of the famed Mondragon co-op in Basque Country as it tries to keep a democratic enterprise going in a capitalist economy.

 

Otherwise, let me add that—my concerns about the continued suppression of socialist and social democratic political ideas in the corporate media taken as given—the times are (a-)changing enough (to invoke the title of Sanders’ recent viral video featuring Ocasio-Cortez) that a sitting congressperson can forthrightly criticize billionaires and get that vital message in front of a mass audience for the first time in a half-century. If only because she is amplified by the massive social movement now propelling Sanders toward the presidency and inadvertently echoed by the ever more shrill and out-of-touch right-wing punditocracy desperate to preserve the economic status quo that has benefitted them so handsomely.

 

May we see more progress advancing such monumentally important ideas into the mass consciousness in the campaign year to come.

 

Apparent Horizon—recipient of 2018 and 2019 Association of Alternative Newsmedia Political Column Awards—is syndicated by the Boston Institute for Nonprofit Journalism. Jason Pramas is BINJ’s executive director, and executive editor and associate publisher of DigBoston. Copyright 2020 Jason Pramas. Licensed for use by the Boston Institute for Nonprofit Journalism and media outlets in its network.

JASON PRAMAS

Executive editor and associate publisher, DigBoston. Executive director of Boston Institute for Nonprofit Journalism. Former founder and editor/publisher of Open Media Boston. 2018 & 2019 Association of Alternative Newsmedia Political Column Award Winner.

More from author
  • JASON PRAMAS
    https://digboston.com/author/jason-pramas/
    Hard right wingers casually tour the Capitol during last week's attack. Via C-SPAN.
    HOW TO DEFEAT THE HARD RIGHT
  • JASON PRAMAS
    https://digboston.com/author/jason-pramas/
    Image CC-BY Salva Barbera 2010
    DO WHATEVER YOU CAN TO HELP YOUR NEIGHBORS IN THIS TIME OF GREAT CRISIS
  • JASON PRAMAS
    https://digboston.com/author/jason-pramas/
    BETTER BOSTON ARTS: MICHAEL LEWY
  • JASON PRAMAS
    https://digboston.com/author/jason-pramas/
    Maria Servellón. Photo courtesy of the artist.
    BETTER BOSTON ARTS: MARIA SERVELLÓN

Filed Under: Apparent Horizon, COLUMNS, NEWS+OPINIONS Tagged With: Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, AOC, Apparent Horizon, Ben Shapiro, Bernie Sanders, Boston Herald, co-operative, Column, contingent work, criticism, Democracy, DigBoston, Elections, Jason Pramas, jobs, labor, Mondragon, policy, Politics, propaganda, social democracy, socialism, worker

WHAT’S NEW

2021 Biden inauguration Boston

PHOTOS & RECAP: “NO HONEYMOON FOR BIDEN” RALLY IN BOSTON

2020 Indian farmers' protest - On a truck. Photo CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain by Randeep Maddoke, randeepphotoartist@gmail.com.

OPINION: IS DISSENT ANTI-NATIONALISM OR PATRIOTISM?

WU ASSERTS THE IMPORTANCE OF THE ARTS IN HER CAMPAIGN

WU ASSERTS THE IMPORTANCE OF THE ARTS IN HER CAMPAIGN

STREET MEDICS BOLSTER PROTESTS IN MORE WAYS THAN YOU MAY REALIZE

STREET MEDICS BOLSTER PROTESTS IN MORE WAYS THAN YOU MAY REALIZE

HOW ONE MASS TOWN TOOK EXTRAORDINARY MEASURES TO APPEASE A CONTROVERSIAL COP

HOW ONE MASS TOWN TOOK EXTRAORDINARY MEASURES TO APPEASE A CONTROVERSIAL COP

MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. HONORED, SPEAKERS ADDRESS RACISM

MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. HONORED, SPEAKERS ADDRESS RACISM

Primary Sidebar

HEMPIRE FREEDOM PACK 25% OFF

FEATURED EVENT

Most Popular

  • APPOINTED SOMERVILLE OFFICIAL SPURS OUTRAGE WITH TWEETS FROM DC MOB SCENE by MARC LEVY
  • Aerial View Parkman Bandstand at Boston Common. CC BY-SA 4.0 2017 by AbhiSuryawanshi. NO HONEYMOON FOR BIDEN: 1/20 PROTEST ON BOSTON COMMON, 4 PM by MATTHEW ANDREWS
  • VIDEO: COP WHO BRAGGED THAT HE HIT PROTESTERS SHOWS HOW BAD APPLES THRIVE IN BOSTON by CHRIS FARAONE
  • PRISON HORRORS BY THE NUMBERS by SARAH BETANCOURT
  • IT’S HARDER THAN EVER TO FIND A BATHROOM IN BOSTON. WHAT’S THE CITY DOING ABOUT IT? by ZACK HUFFMAN

READ CURRENT MEMBER EDITION

DIG Member 1.9 – 11/26/20

READ CURRENT STREET ISSUE

DIG Year End 2020

Footer

digbos

“Trump was voted out. However, this is not a man “Trump was voted out. However, this is not a mandate for #Biden and #Harris.” https://digboston.com/photos-recap-no-honeymoon-for-biden-rally-in-boston/ #photo #rally #march #left #protest #inauguration #Boston #Massachusetts
OPINION: IS DISSENT ANTI-NATIONALISM OR PATRIOTISM OPINION: IS DISSENT ANTI-NATIONALISM OR PATRIOTISM? #Boston #protest for Indian farmers, Saturday 1/23/21, 12-1 pm at the #Massachusetts State House https://digboston.com/opinion-is-dissent-anti-nationalism-or-patriotism/ #India #politics #food #farmer #protest #justice #solidarity @monica_gill1
HOW ONE MASS TOWN TOOK EXTRAORDINARY MEASURES TO A HOW ONE MASS TOWN TOOK EXTRAORDINARY MEASURES TO APPEASE A CONTROVERSIAL COP https://digboston.com/no-justice-how-officials-in-one-mass-town-took-extraordinary-measures-to-appease-a-controversial-cop/ #ArlingtonMA #police #reform #cop #racism #controversy #BlackLivesMatter #Massachusetts
Ghost kitchens simply don’t have a need for host Ghost kitchens simply don’t have a need for hosts, servers, bartenders, bussers … What happens to those #jobs if virtual kitchens continue to flourish? https://digboston.com/ghost-story-virtual-kitchens-appear-to-be-the-next-big-thing-but-at-what-cost/ #restaurant #labor #work #Boston #Massachusetts #coronavirus #COVID19
“I don’t think we’re going to wake up on Jan “I don’t think we’re going to wake up on Jan. 7 in the same country we went to bed in on the 6th.” https://digboston.com/former-mass-gubernatorial-candidate-predicted-violence-before-assault-on-capitol/ #politics #Massachusetts #national #Capitol #WashingtonDC #MAGA
RADICAL AND RELEVANT: THE LIFE OF HARRY BRILL http RADICAL AND RELEVANT: THE LIFE OF HARRY BRILL https://digboston.com/radical-and-relevant-the-life-of-harry-brill/ #obituary #organizer #radical #sociologist #democracy #politics @UMassBoston @BklynCollege411 @UCBerkeley #Boston #Massachusetts #NewYorkCity #Berkeley #California
NO HONEYMOON FOR BIDEN: 1/20 #PROTEST ON BOSTON CO NO HONEYMOON FOR BIDEN: 1/20 #PROTEST ON BOSTON COMMON, 4 PM https://digboston.com/no-honeymoon-for-biden-1-20-protest-on-boston-common-4-pm/ #opinion #progressive #left #action #inauguration #Boston #Massachusetts
Light and sweet and hoppy, we’re loving this lat Light and sweet and hoppy, we’re loving this latest incarnation of a #beer that’s been in the making for months. https://digboston.com/video-jacks-abby-x-boston-celtics-pride-and-parquet-hoppy-lager-unboxing-tasting/ #fun #video #review #Boston #Massachusetts
Jostling for position and influence are the disadv Jostling for position and influence are the disadvantaged candidates, existing industry participants, and municipalities … https://digboston.com/the-road-to-home-delivery-pt-5-dogs-in-the-fight-identifying-the-players/ #cannabis #politics #analysis #Massachusetts
The candidates will be interviewed about the upcom The candidates will be interviewed about the upcoming race. https://digboston.com/wu-and-campbell-to-speak-at-mayoral-candidate-webinar/ #politics #mayor #campaign #Boston #Massachusetts
Load More... Follow on Instagram
Social Buttons

DigBoston facebook DigBoston Twitter DigBoston Instagram

Masthead

About

Submissions

Advertise

Privacy Policy

Customer Service

Distribution

About Us

DigBoston is a one-stop nexus for everything worth doing or knowing in the Boston area. It's an alt-weekly, it's a website, it's an e-mail blast, it's a twitter account, it's that cool party that you were at last night ... hey, you're reading it, so it's gotta be good. For advertising inquiries: [email protected] To reach Editorial: [email protected] For internship opportunities: [email protected]