• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • HOME
  • NEWS+OPINIONS
    • NEWS TO US
    • COLUMNS
      • APPARENT HORIZON
      • DEAR READER
      • Close
    • LONGFORM FEATURES
    • OPINIONS
    • EDITORIAL
    • Close
  • ARTS+ENTERTAINMENT
    • FILM
    • MUSIC
    • COMEDY
    • PERFORMING ARTS
    • VISUAL ARTS
    • Close
  • DINING+DRINKING
    • EATS
    • SIPS
    • Close
  • LIFESTYLE
    • CANNABIS
      • TALKING JOINTS MEMO
      • Close
    • WELLNESS
    • GTFO
    • Close
  • STUFF TO DO
  • TICKETS
  • ABOUT US
    • 5 DOUBLE-U’S
    • MASTHEAD
    • DISTRIBUTION
    • ADVERTISE
    • SUBMISSIONS
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • Close
  • BECOME A MEMBER

Dig Bos

The Dig - Boston's Only Newspaper

READ CURRENT STREET ISSUE

DIG Year End 2020

WHAT TECH CALLS THINKING

Written by PETER BERARD Posted December 26, 2020 Filed Under: Books

Adrian Daub

On the “intellectual bedrock” of Silicon Valley


Silicon Valley promises much to many, but arguably none of its promises are as important as the one the tech industry as a whole makes about breaking with the past. Not just its products, but the industry’s corporate existence, in the industry’s telling, makes everything that came before obsolete. This provides much of the charge behind rhetorical touchstones like “innovation” and especially “disruption.” As such, Stanford professor Adrian Daub’s small new book, What Tech Calls Thinking: An Inquiry into the Intellectual Bedrock of Silicon Valley, gets to the business of letting the air out of the tech industry’s pretensions right at the premise, by insisting that Silicon Valley’s ideas have a past, and that that past matters.

Writing on the tech industry typically remains at one or another of the affective poles of boosterish messianism or febrile panic over the changes the industry has wrought and will bring about in the future. These positions both make a certain degree of sense—the messianism for those who stand to materially benefit from Silicon Valley “disruption,” the panic for the vast majority who do not and are seemingly powerless to stop it. While Daub is a critic of the industry, his approach is less that of outsider-doomsayer and more that of curious, somewhat bemused neighbor. He does, after all, teach at Stanford, and has presumably seen students drop out to pursue the Silicon Valley dream.

In fact, Daub begins his book with an amusing—and informative, if the reader was ever curious about the course offerings at the Ivy of the West Coast—meditation on the importance of “dropping out” in Silicon Valley mythology. Many of the most idolized founders of tech companies were college dropouts, notorious tech villain Peter Thiel pays people to drop out of college, and of course there’s still a ’60s-ish haze over the whole area that lionizes dropping out, presumably so as to tune in and turn on to some other reality. But there are two parts of the dropping-out story, as Daub reminds us. There’s the leaving, yes, to pursue one’s dreams—but there’s also the getting in, to Stanford, Harvard, or wherever else. There’s the importance of the pedigree, the connections made, and as Daub, interested in the lived experience of ideas, makes clear, the concepts half-digested. Elizabeth Holmes, the most infamous Silicon Valley fraud of her generation, took liberal arts courses during her time at Stanford—the usual humanities lament of the incomplete liberal education of technologists isn’t quite right there. More pertinently, Daub points out, she did not finish her biochemistry degree, which might have suggested that the basis of her scam made no sense in the first place.

For the rest of the book, the ideas that form the subtitular “bedrock” of Silicon Valley are less bad in their own right—though there’s little in Ayn Rand, to cite one example, to recommend to anyone over the age of 16—than half-understood, at best, by the executives, technologists, and ideas men who carry them in their heads. Take the ideas of foundational media theorist Marshall McLuhan. It would be asking a lot for anyone to truly take on board McLuhan’s wide-ranging, obscurely written work. In fact, the way in which McLuhan is often only comprehensible in small doses—aphorisms, if we’re being charitable—makes him easier to digest for busy Silicon Valley types. As they would argue and as Daub does too, they take aboard his central thesis, in aphorism form, naturally: The medium is the message. Platform matters more than content. Those who can see that—the engineers of the platform—matter more than those who provide the content, even if said platform would be irrelevant without content.

And so it goes, down the line, as Daub details ideas that are either half-understood or only half-ideas filling the space where a more thoughtful way of being might exist in the most powerful industry in the world. Ayn Rand’s individualism departs from the anti-totalitarianism it cribbed from by insisting that everyday selfishness was enough to make someone a hero and a genius, a resister of tyranny. Along with providing a pleasing self-image for Silicon Valley figures like Elon Musk, Randian posturing also allows for the elision of the thousands of workers, from coders to janitors, that make Silicon Valley possible, subsuming them under the figure of the maverick genius entrepreneur. A considerably less well-known crank, Rene Girard, has also had an outsized impact on how Silicon Valley sees itself. This came about less through the power of his ideas—an obscure farrago insisting that all human action is built on “mimetic desire,” the desire to have what others have—than for the ways in which it reaffirms what figures like Peter Thiel already liked to believe.

Numerous critics have discussed the connections between countercultural thought and practice and Silicon Valley, most notably in the great From Counterculture to Cyberculture by historian Fred Turner (who Daub lists in the acknowledgements of his book). Geographically, Silicon Valley is located right between the countercultural epicenter of San Francisco (which the tech industry is currently metabolizing) and the central coast of California, home of numerous centers of New Age practice. Esalen, the ur-New Age establishment, has numerous tech industry links, and Daub discusses the ways in which the ideas of a cleansed or enhanced consciousness, the communications theories of figures like Claude Shannon, and tech industry profit motive coalesce. New Age spirituality a la Esalen seeks out perfect means of perception and communication; information theory makes clear that entropy, confusion, and surprise are part of all communications, and in fact that as channels for communication multiply, so do opportunities for entropy. So you get the promise of free, unmediated communication across the globe through technology, and what you receive are platforms full of ads, Nazis, and dick pics. Like any good capitalist, Silicon Valley titans position themselves to profit both from the exalted promise and the degraded reality while denying responsibility for the incongruence.

The concept of “disruption” as an important force for progress traces back to more serious figures: Austrian political economist Joseph Schumpeter, who was attempting to put a liberal, free-market gloss on ideas derived from Karl Marx. Inevitably, though, Silicon Valley dumbed it down for its own advantage. Marx and Schumpeter both thought that the disruptiveness of capitalism would lead to something different; if nothing else, a new stasis that further disrupters would alter in a cycle, the “creative destruction” Schumpeter discovered. In Daub’s telling, the tech industry has decontextualized “creative destruction,” which was meant to apply to monopolies, into “disruption,” which applies to anything at all, and invests the disrupter with the halo of innovation and improvement, even if all they’re doing is taking an existing industry—taxicabs, for instance, or hotels—and ignoring its safety regulations and unions. Like many of the key Silicon Valley concepts Daub illuminates, “disruption” is at once all-encompassing, all-promising, and ultimately a weak variation of older ideas.

Daub packs a lot into a short book. The attention he pays to any one given thinker is necessarily limited, but his summations are highly competent and succinct. The overall picture he paints is grim, but in a different way from most ringing the alarm bells about tech industry overreach. He finds truth in many of the jokes about “disruptive” tech and the culture that creates it: that many of the most ballyhooed innovations are “solutions” to the problems of no longer living with one’s mother or in a dorm, that many highfalutin ideas from objectivism to the singularity are essentially astrology for men who fancy themselves rational. Many ideas and cultural styles seem to cling to Silicon Valley by virtue of location: the countercultural fallout from San Francisco, Rene Girard’s tenure at Stanford, and so on. More than any master plan, Daub presents the juggernaut of Silicon Valley as driven by lazy thinking, assumptions, and path dependency. This might provide scant relief for those crushed by its progress, but it is, presumably, a good thing to know.


WHAT TECH CALLS THINKING: AN INQUIRY INTO THE INTELLECTUAL BEDROCK OF SILICON VALLEY. ADRIAN DAUB. FARRAH STRAUSS AND GIROUX. 160 PP. $15.

PETER BERARD

Peter Berard is a writer and organizer who lives in Watertown, MA. For more of his work, check out peterberard.substack.com.

More from author
  • PETER BERARD
    https://digboston.com/author/peter-berard/
    REVIEW: BLACK RADICAL AUTHOR KERRI K. GREENIDGE
  • PETER BERARD
    https://digboston.com/author/peter-berard/
    Rick Perlstein, author, Reaganland: America’s Right Turn 1976-1980. Photo by Meg Handler.
    BOOK REVIEW: REAGANLAND
  • PETER BERARD
    https://digboston.com/author/peter-berard/
    Andrew Bacevich. Photo courtesy of Metropolitan Books.
    AGE OF ILLUSIONS: BACEVICH LOOKS AT AMERICA’S LOST TIME

Filed Under: Books Tagged With: Adrian Daub, silicon valley, What Tech Calls Thinking: An Inquiry into the Intellectual Bedrock of Silicon Valley

WHAT’S NEW

IT'S HARDER THAN EVER TO FIND A BATHROOM IN BOSTON. WHAT'S THE CITY DOING ABOUT IT?

IT’S HARDER THAN EVER TO FIND A BATHROOM IN BOSTON. WHAT’S THE CITY DOING ABOUT IT?

ON NATIONAL DAY OF ACTION, PROTESTERS CALL FOR EVICTION MORATORIUM

ON NATIONAL DAY OF ACTION, PROTESTERS CALL FOR EVICTION MORATORIUM

WU AND CAMPBELL TO SPEAK AT MAYORAL CANDIDATE WEBINAR

WU AND CAMPBELL TO SPEAK AT MAYORAL CANDIDATE WEBINAR

Hard right wingers casually tour the Capitol during last week's attack. Via C-SPAN.

HOW TO DEFEAT THE HARD RIGHT

BAKER URGED TO SIGN GAME CHANGING CLIMATE BILL

BAKER URGED TO SIGN GAME CHANGING CLIMATE BILL

APPOINTED SOMERVILLE OFFICIAL SPURS OUTRAGE WITH TWEETS FROM DC MOB SCENE

APPOINTED SOMERVILLE OFFICIAL SPURS OUTRAGE WITH TWEETS FROM DC MOB SCENE

Primary Sidebar

HEMPIRE FREEDOM PACK 25% OFF

FEATURED EVENT

Most Popular

  • APPOINTED SOMERVILLE OFFICIAL SPURS OUTRAGE WITH TWEETS FROM DC MOB SCENE by MARC LEVY
  • INSIDE THE FIGHT TO DOCUMENT THE HORRORS AT AMERICA’S OLDEST WOMEN’S PRISON by SHELBY GREBBIN AND ISHA MARATHE
  • VIDEO: COP WHO BRAGGED THAT HE HIT PROTESTERS SHOWS HOW BAD APPLES THRIVE IN BOSTON by CHRIS FARAONE
  • THE WSJ FEATURE ON WORCESTER’S POLICE CHIEF IS PURE COPAGANDA by BILL SHANER
  • STATE LOOKS TO SPEND $75K TO PREVENT FUTURE STORROWINGS by DAN ATKINSON

READ CURRENT MEMBER EDITION

DIG Member 1.9 – 11/26/20

READ CURRENT STREET ISSUE

DIG Year End 2020

Footer

digbos

Light and sweet and hoppy, we’re loving this lat Light and sweet and hoppy, we’re loving this latest incarnation of a #beer that’s been in the making for months. https://digboston.com/video-jacks-abby-x-boston-celtics-pride-and-parquet-hoppy-lager-unboxing-tasting/ #fun #video #review #Boston #Massachusetts
Jostling for position and influence are the disadv Jostling for position and influence are the disadvantaged candidates, existing industry participants, and municipalities … https://digboston.com/the-road-to-home-delivery-pt-5-dogs-in-the-fight-identifying-the-players/ #cannabis #politics #analysis #Massachusetts
The candidates will be interviewed about the upcom The candidates will be interviewed about the upcoming race. https://digboston.com/wu-and-campbell-to-speak-at-mayoral-candidate-webinar/ #politics #mayor #campaign #Boston #Massachusetts
Participants took to the streets in the hope of sw Participants took to the streets in the hope of swaying the Biden administration. https://digboston.com/on-national-day-of-action-protesters-call-for-eviction-moratorium/ #housing #justice #protest #national #Boston #Massachusetts
“They refuse to respond to this humanitarian cri “They refuse to respond to this humanitarian crisis where people really need them. We’re just ignoring this problem and it’s getting worse and worse.” https://digboston.com/its-harder-than-ever-to-find-a-bathroom-in-boston-whats-the-city-doing-about-it/ #politics #unhoused #homeless #bathroom #public #health #Boston #Massachusetts
Environmental #justice and #climate change advocat Environmental #justice and #climate change advocates are pushing for its passage. https://digboston.com/baker-urged-to-sign-game-changing-climate-bill/ #environment #globalwarming #legislation #politics #Massachusetts
In short, it’s amazing. For details, check the # In short, it’s amazing. For details, check the #video … https://digboston.com/video-night-shifts-tea-party-is-subtle-love-for-people-who-hate-most-hard-teas/ #review #fun #beer @NightShiftBeer
HOW TO DEFEAT THE HARD RIGHT: Some thoughts on the HOW TO DEFEAT THE HARD RIGHT: Some thoughts on the Capitol attack and building a more democratic nation. The latest from DigBoston's @jasonpramas. https://digboston.com/how-to-defeat-the-hard-right/ #democracy #politics #Capitol #US #America #attack #Biden #Trump #grassroots #movement #analysis #strategy #MAGA
“Should Mayor Walsh be confirmed by the Senate, “Should Mayor Walsh be confirmed by the Senate, I am ready to take the reins and lead our city through these difficult times.” https://digboston.com/walsh-to-wash-janey-to-become-1st-black-boston-mayor-1st-woman-to-lead-city/ #politics #Boston #Massachusetts #BlackLivesMatter
APPOINTED #SOMERVILLE #OFFICIAL SPURS #OUTRAGE WIT APPOINTED #SOMERVILLE #OFFICIAL SPURS #OUTRAGE WITH TWEETS FROM DC #MOB SCENE: Mayor Curtatone says “We’re taking it seriously and doing our due diligence” https://digboston.com/appointed-somerville-official-spurs-outrage-with-tweets-from-dc-mob-scene/ #politics #controversy #Massachusetts #Capitol #Congress #WashingtonDC #MAGA #Trump
Load More... Follow on Instagram
Social Buttons

DigBoston facebook DigBoston Twitter DigBoston Instagram

Masthead

About

Submissions

Advertise

Privacy Policy

Customer Service

Distribution

About Us

DigBoston is a one-stop nexus for everything worth doing or knowing in the Boston area. It's an alt-weekly, it's a website, it's an e-mail blast, it's a twitter account, it's that cool party that you were at last night ... hey, you're reading it, so it's gotta be good. For advertising inquiries: [email protected] To reach Editorial: [email protected] For internship opportunities: [email protected]