• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • HOME
  • NEWS+OPINIONS
    • NEWS TO US
    • COLUMNS
      • APPARENT HORIZON
      • DEAR READER
      • Close
    • LONGFORM FEATURES
    • OPINIONS
    • EDITORIAL
    • Close
  • ARTS+ENTERTAINMENT
    • FILM
    • MUSIC
    • COMEDY
    • PERFORMING ARTS
    • VISUAL ARTS
    • Close
  • DINING+DRINKING
    • EATS
    • SIPS
    • Close
  • LIFESTYLE
    • CANNABIS
      • TALKING JOINTS MEMO
      • Close
    • WELLNESS
    • GTFO
    • Close
  • STUFF TO DO
  • TICKETS
  • ABOUT US
    • ABOUT
    • MASTHEAD
    • ADVERTISE
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • Close
  • BECOME A MEMBER

Dig Bos

The Dig - Boston's Only Newspaper

CURRENT STREET EDITION

DIG 23.05 – 4/8/21

PREDICTING THE UNPREDICTABLE: LOCAL ELECTION SOOTHSAYERS TELL ALL

Written by RICH TENORIO Posted December 2, 2020 Filed Under: News, News to Us, NEWS+OPINIONS

This year’s election was as unpredictable as 2016

“There’s always a little bit of a social tendency to say they’d done it when maybe it’s in the mailbox”


A blue wave? It ebbed against a Republican shoreline.

Democrat victories in red states like Florida and Texas? Both were called early for President Trump.

In the end, Democrats barely held on to a majority in the House, they’re counting on two runoff victories in Georgia to take the Senate, and as for the presidency, the General Services Administration did not sign off on the start of Joe Biden’s transition until Nov. 23.

After the 2016 election resulted in some second-guessing of the polls, now similar questions are being raised about how the pollsters could have made some errant predictions again. Based on conversations with experts in the Boston area, it seems like predicting the unpredictable was once again their dilemma this time around.

One source of unpredictability in American politics the last few years has been President Trump. The phenomenon of the “shy Trump voter” entered the American lexicon, although experts said that in the end, it wasn’t as sizable as sometimes made out to be.

“We did not feel he had enough to win,” said David Paleologos, director of the Suffolk University Political Research Center. “It’s kind of what happened. There were shy voters in the blue wall states. I think there were more in 2016.”

“The candidate was very unpredictable,” Paleologos said. “It also happens if people feel that a candidate represents qualities that are polarizing and distasteful.”

Yet the difficulty of gauging support for the incumbent went beyond shy Trump voters.

“I think the most likely candidate is that in the presidential year, we apparently saw some fraction of Trump supporters just not respond to the polls,” said Charles Stewart III, director of the Stanford-MIT Healthy Elections Project and of the MIT Election Lab. “It was not the ‘shy Trump supporter’ phenomenon, but what’s called a nonresponse bias.” And, Stewart said, “You did not need a whole lot of Trump supporters not responding to create the errors we’re seeing.”

Paleologos reflected on the challenge of “a slice of electorate that is not comfortable giving you information.”

“If you say you’re undecided, they can’t mark you down as a Trump voter,” he explained. “I can look at the data. [Someone said they were] undecided between Trump and Biden. They said they don’t like Biden and are unsure about Trump. They gave Trump high job approval. I can say they’re probably a Trump voter but I can’t change the data. We have to assume they are undecided.”

Trump complicated the situation in other ways, including with last-minute, COVID-defying rallies.

“It seemed for close to two weeks, he was feverishly barnstorming,” said Thomas Patterson, the Bradlee Professor of Government and the Press at Harvard Kennedy School. “He seemed to have some ability to mobilize Republicans who may not have voted otherwise. In the pollster model, they may look like nonvoters, given the responses they made.”

The last-ditch Trump get-out-the-vote effort occurred just as the polls were winding down their final tallies.

“It’s no good to do a poll Tuesday morning,” Patterson said of Election Day. “They always miss the last day or two. … It’s pretty clear from the exit polls that Trump got a disproportionate number of the late deciders,” picking up an estimated difference of close to a point.

Despite his controversiality—or because of it?—he captured almost 95% of Republican voters, a two-point improvement upon 2016. And if there were shy Trump voters, there were also Trump voters who were anything but. Pollster Paleologos said that some individuals told pollsters that they were “proud to state that” they liked Trump.

Another unpredictability looming over the election was not a candidate but a virus: COVID-19. The ways in which people could vote suddenly multiplied to include mail-in ballots and early voting as well as the traditional in-person vote on Election Day. The mail-in ballots have drawn criticism from Trump since they were first offered as an alternative to voters concerned about casting a ballot during the pandemic.

“Perhaps mail-in voting and early voting may have affected the results,” Patterson said, positing that a respondent may have told a pollster that they already voted but had not. “There’s always a little bit of a social tendency to say they’d done it when maybe it’s in the mailbox.”

Between the flood of mail-in ballots and the evaporated blue wave, maybe it’s hard to remember the last time the pollsters were questioned so thoroughly, in 2016. Well, the pollsters do remember those days.

“The national polls in 2016 were not wrong,” Paleologos reflected. “The RealClearPolitics average had Hillary Clinton winning the popular vote by three points. She ended up winning by two points. The national polls were closer four years ago than this time. This time, the national polls were a little far farther off. They had Biden winning by higher than what happened in 2016.

“In the blue wall states—specifically Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania—the polls were far off. Anyone polling those states got the scrutiny.”

Paleologos and other experts said that inexperienced state pollsters misfired on calling individual states four years ago.

“There were polls in 2016 done in blue wall states,” he said. “They were not top-rated public university pollsters with access to 538.com, Nate Silver, his rating system.”

“There were bad state polls in 2016,” said MIT’s Stewart. “They had a tendency to overestimate Hillary Clinton votes.” He added, “Simply, state polls were more likely to be made by people new to the field. There were a lot of start-up state polls in 2016. They did not have the experience necessary, the research necessary, to do state polling correctly.”

He notes, “That does not explain 2020,” when there are “a number of state polling organizations that are really quite established.”

It’s one more reflection of what made this election so unpredictable, even for those whose job is to predict it.

“We take the temperature of the popular vote or state vote,” Paleologos said. “It’s increasingly complex and challenging because the nation is so divided.

“In our last national poll, one of our most significant findings, bigger than 2016, is that 66% feel the divisions in our country are greater than they’ve ever been before. It’s probably the right number. Democrats and Republicans both agree the divisions are so deep. It’s why Biden talks about healing so much in his speeches since the election. The divide has the potential to deepen. Ultimately, the country has to reconcile the differences.”

RICH TENORIO

Rich Tenorio is a writer and editor whose work has appeared in international, national, regional and local media outlets. He is a graduate of Harvard College and the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism. He is also a cartoonist.

More from author
  • RICH TENORIO
    https://digboston.com/author/rich-tenorio/
    POET AND UMASS AMHERST PROF MARTÍN ESPADA: “THIS BOOK IS … MASSACHUSETTS. IT’S WHO I AM.”
  • RICH TENORIO
    https://digboston.com/author/rich-tenorio/
    THE ANOMALIES OF ‘OUMUAMUA
  • RICH TENORIO
    https://digboston.com/author/rich-tenorio/
    INTERVIEW WITH “RURAL REBELLION” AUTHOR ROSS BENES
  • RICH TENORIO
    https://digboston.com/author/rich-tenorio/
    NEWS THROWBACK: CHALLENGING A MISINFORMED ANTI-VAXXER MOVEMENT, THEN AND NOW

Filed Under: News, News to Us, NEWS+OPINIONS Tagged With: Donald Trump, Election, Joe Biden

WHAT’S NEW

Massachusetts National Guard by The National Guard is licensed under CC BY 2.0

CORONAVIRUS UPDATE: DON’T LET YOUR GUARD DOWN

BRIDGES AND BUDGETS: PUTTING THE COUNTRY BACK TOGETHER, FROM BOSTON TO BIDEN

BRIDGES AND BUDGETS: PUTTING THE COUNTRY BACK TOGETHER, FROM BOSTON TO BIDEN

SPECIAL FEATURE: UNCHARTED WATERS

SPECIAL FEATURE: UNCHARTED WATERS

THE OPPONENT: NEWCOMER MCBRIDE TAKES ON BAKER IN D3

THE OPPONENT: NEWCOMER MCBRIDE TAKES ON BAKER IN D3

THE IMPORTANT ART STOLEN FROM BOSTON THAT NOBODY SEEMS TO CARE ABOUT

THE IMPORTANT ART STOLEN FROM BOSTON THAT NOBODY SEEMS TO CARE ABOUT

PICS & RECAP: JUSTICE 4 DUANTE WRIGHT JUSTICE 4 ALL EMERGENCY RALLY 

PICS & RECAP: JUSTICE 4 DUANTE WRIGHT JUSTICE 4 ALL EMERGENCY RALLY 

Primary Sidebar

HEMPIRE FREEDOM PACK 25% OFF

FEATURED EVENT

Most Popular

  • VACCINE EQUITY NOW! COALITION ASKS BAKER TO ALLOCATE 20% OF NEW DOSES TO HARD HIT COMMUNITIES by ZIQI WANG
  • IF YOU’RE SURPRISED THE BPD CODDLED AN ACCUSED MOLESTER COP, YOU’RE NOT PAYING ATTENTION by CHRIS FARAONE
  • THE MYSTERY OF CHEZ TORTONI by CHRISTOPHER EHLERS
  • THE IMPORTANT ART STOLEN FROM BOSTON THAT NOBODY SEEMS TO CARE ABOUT by CHRIS FARAONE
  • A FAREWELL TRIBUTE (OF SORTS) TO MARTY WALSH by DIG STAFF

READ CURRENT MEMBER EDITION

DIG Member 2.1 – March 2021

READ CURRENT STREET ISSUE

DIG 23.05 – 4/8/21

Footer

digbos

digbos
Putting the country back together, from Boston to Putting the country back together, from Boston to Biden. https://digboston.com/bridges-and-budgets-putting-the-country-back-together-from-boston-to-biden/ #news #analysis #infrastructure #Boston #Massachusetts
CORONAVIRUS UPDATE: DON’T LET YOUR GUARD DOWN. K CORONAVIRUS UPDATE: DON’T LET YOUR GUARD DOWN. Keep wearing masks and social distancing until public health officials say it’s safe to stop. The latest from DigBoston's @jasonpramas. https://digboston.com/coronavirus-update-dont-let-your-guard-down/ #health #publichealth #mask #vaccine #politics #Boston #Massachusetts #coronavirus #COVID19
“My administration is doubling down on our work “My administration is doubling down on our work to stand up the #Boston Office of #Police Accountability and Transparency.” https://digboston.com/politicians-get-in-line-to-call-for-boston-police-accountability/ #politics #Massachusetts
This week is your last chance to hit up Mooby’s This week is your last chance to hit up Mooby’s in #Boston … https://digboston.com/moobys-boston-how-kevin-smith-has-brought-his-pick-up-experience-to-10-cities-during-the-pandemic/ #fan #popup #fun #restaurant #movie #Massachusetts #snoochieboochies
The group is asking that polices address the dispa The group is asking that polices address the disparities the #data has revealed. https://digboston.com/parents-release-an-analysis-of-boston-public-school-fundraising-inequities/ #education #school #public #study #fundraising #racism #Boston #Massachusetts
“We’re not going to survive for 20 more years “We’re not going to survive for 20 more years if we don’t do this [move to a bigger space].” https://digboston.com/how-juliet-hit-a-100k-kickstarter-goal-in-4-days/ #restaurant #business #food #crowdfund #SomervilleMA #coronavirus #COVID19
EDITORIAL: DIGBOSTON SEEKS CLIMATE IDEAS FOR MAYOR EDITORIAL: DIGBOSTON SEEKS CLIMATE IDEAS FOR MAYOR KIM JANEY. Environmental organizations and individual activists invited to submit opinion articles for publication. https://digboston.com/editorial-digboston-seeks-climate-ideas-for-mayor-kim-janey/ #politics @boston_mayor #environment #globalwarming #climate #activist #callforsubmissions #policy #Boston #Massachusetts
“Most are some of my favorite bars or local clas “Most are some of my favorite bars or local classics that I’ve learned to love in my time living in the city. Others just have a great facade that I know would make a great drawing.” https://digboston.com/drawn-but-not-forgotten-local-artist-sketches-beloved-boston-restaurants/ #art #artist #sketch #drawing #Boston #Massachusetts #bar #restaurant
Despite #pandemic hurdles, Mass #music instructors Despite #pandemic hurdles, Mass #music instructors hit new high notes. “My #teaching has gone to another level.” https://digboston.com/the-medium-is-the-maestro/ #education #Massachusetts #coronavirus #COVID19
From the podcast to the book, Wayne Federman chron From the podcast to the book, Wayne Federman chronicles the business of joke-telling. https://digboston.com/the-history-of-stand-up-from-mark-twain-to-dave-chappelle/ #comedy #history #book #interview #Boston #Massachusetts
Load More... Follow on Instagram
Social Buttons

DigBoston facebook DigBoston Twitter DigBoston Instagram

Masthead

About

Submissions

Advertise

Privacy Policy

Customer Service

Distribution

About Us

DigBoston is a one-stop nexus for everything worth doing or knowing in the Boston area. It's an alt-weekly, it's a website, it's an e-mail blast, it's a twitter account, it's that cool party that you were at last night ... hey, you're reading it, so it's gotta be good. For advertising inquiries: [email protected] To reach Editorial: [email protected] For internship opportunities: [email protected]